The Autoware Maps and Map Formats Working Group Meeting, held on 1 August 2019 (see Autoware Maps and Map Formats working group: Meeting minutes 24 July 2019 - Autoware - Open Robotics Discourse)
We evaluated 4 possible simulators for their compatibility with maps.
that we considered under the following criteria:
- map support - are maps supported?
- diversity of formats - multiple formats?
- import/export
- extensibility/openness
During the discussion that followed we did a comparative evaluation of the various simulators and scored them as follows:
Summary
Scale (1=bad 5=good)
| Criteria |
Gazebo |
Carla |
LGSVL |
Cognata |
| Map support? |
2 |
3 |
4 |
4 |
| Diversity of formats? |
1 |
2 (OpenDRIVE) |
3 |
3 |
| Export/import |
1 |
1 |
2 |
? |
| Extensibility/Open? |
5 |
4 |
2 |
1 |
|
|
|
|
|
| Total |
9 |
10 |
11 |
? |
Perhaps unsurprisingly, the working group did not recommend any specific simulator, but Carla and LGSVL are more suitable in the short term due to being able to load maps.
At the next meeting @mitsudome-r and @simon-t4 agreed to present the ongoing work by Tier4 to support OSM XML and Lanelet2. Please vote for the time of the next meeting.
The following meeting will review map use cases - with a view to deriving maps requirements - from the following perspectives:
- OpenPlanner + objection detection + prediction - @Hatem
- Traffic regulation - @simon-t4
- Semantic map localisation - @oscar
- LanesPlanner - @mitsudome-r
1 Like
@Brian_Holt Thanks for the minutes summary. Regarding Cognata export/import criteria, From what I understand you can import from OpenDrive and DriveWorks formats, and Cognata is willing to develop other file proxies for requested formats. When building they typically read in a supported HD map format and construct their own 3D map with their own HD map format. I am unsure if Cognata can export the result to OpenDrive. I recommend a similar ranking to LGSVL and Carla in that category.
Votinh is now closed for the meeting time, it is scheduled for Friday, August 9, 2019 1:00 PM
Brian Holt is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.
Topic: Autoware Map Data Working Group #4
Time: Aug 9, 2019 02:00 PM London
Join Zoom Meeting
One tap mobile
+496971049922,189827461# Germany
+493030806188,189827461# Germany
Dial by your location
+49 69 7104 9922 Germany
+49 30 3080 6188 Germany
+49 30 5679 5800 Germany
+1 929 436 2866 US (New York)
+1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose)
Meeting ID: 189 827 461
Find your local number: Zoom International Dial-in Numbers - Zoom
@Brian_Holt
Thank you for holding the meeting!
Here is the presentation about Lanelet2 integration to autoware.ai v1.13
1 Like
Hi all and @Brian_Holt.
My name is Alon. I’m a software simulation engineer at Foretellix,
an Israeli based Start-Up that tackles the issues regarding AV safety verification.
I’m very interested in Autoware in general and in this WG specifically
Hopefully i will be able to contribute ASAP to one of the WG.
Now here is my question:
It seems that the video recording you linked is from the last meeting (9/8) and i can’t find the recording about the simulations from 2/8. where can i find it plz?
Best regards
Alon.
Hi @alonSheader and welcome to the Autoware community! You’re very welcome to join the next meeting, I’ve just posted details.
Apologies for not putting up the recording for the simulator presentations. Here is it: Video Conferencing, Web Conferencing, Webinars, Screen Sharing - Zoom. It was really late at night and I think I just forgot to do so.
